Makerbot Industries launched the Replicator 2 and received many positive responses. The Replicator 2 has a layer resolution of 100µ (0.0039 in) and offers a build envelope of 11.2 x 6.0 x 6.1 in. (28.5 x 15.3 x 15.5 cm) which are comparable to professional desktop 3D printers. However among all the positive voices, we see also angers.
That's because, Replicator 2 is rumored to go closed sourced.
Josef Prusa, creator of Prusa Mendel, probably the most wide spread 3D printer, raised the issue in his blog, "Makerbot turned closed source, or at least all the signals lead to it.". Makerbot is based on RepRap, and started by one of the RepRap core developers, Zach Smith, Bre Pettis and Adam Mayer. Adrian Bowyer, founder of the RepRap Project, also funded the start-up.
Makerbot has their open source roots. But it seems Replicator 2 will be closed-source Replicator 2. In his letter to Bre Pettis, Prusa asked, "we know each other for some time. I want to ask you about the Replicator 2, and if it's closed source? If so, then why?"
Bre Pettis, co-founder and CEO of Makerbot Industries, made a statement in their latest blog, "There is some misinformation that I'd like to clear up."
We're working that out and we are going to be as open as we possibly can while building a sustainable business. We are going to continue to respect licenses and continue to contribute to the open technology of 3D printing, some of which we initiated. We don't want to abuse the goodwill and support of our community.
Maybe they can make it clear at the World Maker Faire next week. Bre Pettis will be speaking at the Open Source Hardware Association conference next week - "Challenges of Open Source Consumer Products."
As Bre mentioned, they have the pressures, the need to be profitable and "support it's 150 employees with jobs, make awesome hardware, and be sustainable".
We'll have to wait to see what parts will be in the open source. Obviously Makerbot needs to take more careful steps in handling the transition from open to closed hardware.
Rob Giseburt posted this to the Make blog:
MakerBot is obviously creating with a much more complex device, with equally more complex supply-chain issues and tech support overhead. There is no doubt a need to remain competitive and profitable. After all, they have to be able to afford to put food on the employees' tables along with continuing R&D to stay ahead of the competition. These are very real problems that have complex solutions.
But it doesn't appear that being closed source and using patents and licensing will free any company from competitors, but instead will only open them to a different form of competitors. A form of competitor that really, truly is only there for the profit, and doesn't have the ethics of open and community driven innovation.
And, after all, the target market of MakerBot, along with many open source hardware companies, is the full spectrum of makers. Not just makers of competing 3D printers, but makers of all sorts: artists, industrial designers, engineers, high-school teachers, biology professors, electrical engineers, architects, etc. Makers don't want black-box trinkets. They want something that, if they want to open it up and learn how it works, they can. They can also, as Massimo Banzi said, scratch their own itch and solve whatever problem they are having, furthering the technology for the entire community.
Is it fine for you that Makerbot's 3D printers being closed source? Or, can we assume that we could finally get a 3D printer with enough support, proper service and warranty? And when a part or machine is broken we could get replacement or refund?
Posted in 3D Printers
Maybe you also like:
- Introducing four new personal 3D printers
- The 2nd Gen of the multi-material Imagine 3D printer
- 2BEIGH3 3D printer call for 60 material testers
- TangiBot 3D Printer - a Makerbot Replicator clone
- Israeli student develops largest 3D porcelain printer (video)
- Eco-friendly robotic 3D printer produces architecture from soil on-site
- First open source powder-based 3D printer
- Fully assembled Afinia H-Series 3D printer launched
- Manufacture on the go: a digital fabrication briefcase with 3D printer and CNC mill
- Build a briefcase 3D printer that you can take everywhere
- Ditto 3D printer now available on Indiegogo
- Rostock: an amazing delta robot 3D printer prototype
- Solidscape launches high precision fully automated 3Z Pro 3D printer
- Maxit 3D printer official launch announced
- Some tips for getting better 3D printing results
- How to unpack, start up and shut down 3D-ONE 3D printer
- Foldable Foldarap 3d printer launches a crowdfunding campaign on Ulule